Both Flesh and Not: Essays by David Foster Wallace

Book Summary

Both Flesh and Not: Essays by David Foster Wallace, published for the first time after his death in 2012. In this book, which consists of fifteen literary essays, Wallace examines human life and its realities from a philosophical and innovative perspective, significantly revealing the author's inquisitive mind. One of these essays relates to a speech he gave in 2005 to his fellow graduates.

"This Is Water" is the title of one of the essays in which Wallace articulates his first and last speech, referencing concepts about human life that perhaps few have paid attention to before. Another essay titled "A View from Mrs. Thompson's House" discusses the tragic events of September 11, 2001, which left unforgettable impacts on human lives.

An intriguing title of another essay is "Consider the Lobster," where the author shares his experiences on the central coasts of America, along with ethical and philosophical questions. Additionally, there is an essay titled "Federer" dedicated to the rivalry between Federer and Nadal, champions of the beautiful sport of tennis, using this context to discuss impossible feats that he himself admires.

David Foster Wallace captivates readers in this work, as he presents storytelling and essay writing in a novel way, utilizing unique vocabulary and definitions, ultimately creating a thought-provoking piece. It is also essential to note that one of the main goals of "This Is Water" is to remind people to live better lives through a change in perspective, understanding the importance of empathy and understanding others, and increasing awareness.

About the Author

David Foster Wallace was an American author born on February 21, 1962, in New York. Coming from a cultural family, he earned his bachelor's degree from Amherst College and his master's degree in creative writing from the University of Arizona. He always sought ways to revive human interactions in today's world, which, despite itself, has led to human isolation.

During his lifetime, Wallace authored works such as Infinite Jest, something to do with paying attention, The Broom of the System, The Pale King, and Everything and more: A compact history of infinity. However, on September 12, 2008, he committed suicide in Claremont, California, ending his life.

Who Should Read the Book?

As mentioned in the introduction, since the work includes philosophical and literary essays, those interested in such themes can include this book in their reading list.

Book Quotes

If you are absolutely sure that you know what the truth is and what really matters, then like me, you won't consider possibilities that are neither pointless nor annoying. But if you have truly learned how to think, how to pay attention, then you will have other options as well. In fact, it is up to you to not only make chaotic, noisy, slow, and hellish situations meaningful but sacred as well.

Almost everyone who loves tennis and has been following men's tennis competitions on television in recent years has had moments that could be called "Federer Moments." These moments are when, while watching the young Swiss player's game, your jaw drops, your eyes bulge out, and a sound is produced that draws spouses from another room to the TV to check if you're okay. These moments intensify if you've played enough tennis to understand how impossible what Federer just did right before your eyes truly is.

The house I eventually sit in, with hair soaked in shampoo, and watch the horror unfold, belongs to Mrs. Thompson, one of the coolest seventy-four-year-olds in the world, and exactly the kind of person you know you can go to her house in an emergency even if her phone is busy. She lives about one or two kilometers from my house and across from some trailer homes. The streets are not crowded but still haven't emptied out as much as one might expect. Mrs. Thompson's house is one of those neat and tidy single-story buildings that are called "bungalows" in the western U.S. and is located south of Bloomington.

Now that I look back at it, the first signs of potential shock were that I didn't ring the doorbell and just walked in; something that is unusual in this town. Mrs. T., thanks in part to her son's business connections, has a forty-inch flat Philips TV that Dan Rather appears on for a moment with his dress shirt and slightly tousled hair (apparently, people in Bloomington have an unbearable preference for CBS news. It's unclear why). There are other women from church present here as well, but I don't know if I've greeted any of them because as far as I remember when I walked in, everyone was glued to one of those few pieces of footage that CBS never aired again, showing a wide shot of the North Tower and its bare scaffolding burning on the upper floors, with dots separating from the building and disappearing into the smoke below, followed by a sudden close-up shot revealing that those dots are real people, wearing suits and ties and skirts and shoes that fell with their owners.

We might have a total of ten nice weather days in Bloomington, and September 11th is one of them. The weather is clear and mild, and after a few weeks of feeling like we’re living under someone's armpit, there’s a pleasant dryness. The serious harvest season hasn’t arrived yet when the pollen from the area makes the air unbearable, and a large percentage of the city is high on Benadryl, which you probably know can give your mornings a dreamy and waterlogged quality. In terms of time zone, we are about an hour behind the eastern states.

Get book

Buy on Amazon
  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Back Bay Books; Reprint edition (November 19, 2013)
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • Paperback ‏ : ‎ 336 pages
  • ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0316182389
  • ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0316182386
  • Item Weight ‏ : ‎ 10.4 ounces
  • Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 5.5 x 1 x 8.25 inches
  • Best Sellers Rank: #579,389 in Books

Related Books

wave
Toxic People by Lillian Glass
How to Help Your Husband Get Ahead by Dorothy Reeder Carnegie
The Odyssey by Homer
Man's Search for Meaning by Viktor E. Frankl
The Compound Effect by Darren Hardy
Add Review
wave
reload, if the code cannot be seen

Book Reviews

wave
  • Mike Dahlstrom

    Mike Dahlstrom


    But the food for thought that characterizes all of Wallaces work. A consistently deep and satisfying author, this is a book best consumed over time so that one may consider all he offers on a wide range of topics. The final essay, "Just Asking", may well be the finest bit of prose written about 9/11 and the "War on Terror" in the 11 years since that day.
  • J. Edgar Mihelic, MA, MA, MBA

    J. Edgar Mihelic, MA, MA, MBA


    So, a writer you like dies. Lets say that they die young. Once you get over the tragedy, you can be mad. It makes sense. You wanted this person to continue to entertain you until the end of your days.

    Now that theyre dead, they cant do that, and you get angry.

    So of course the question to ask is: does this person have anything sitting around that can be issued?
    David Foster Wallace was nice enough to leave some droppings. First there was an incomplete novel, "The Pale King". It was about a Midwestern IRS employee in the 80s. It was about as fun as splitting together the footnotes to Infinite Jest with the tax code. I couldnt tell you much more. I only got 30 pages in.
    For the truth though, I didnt like IJ. I spent a whole summer struggling through it wondering what was so great about all of this - finding flashes of brilliance while working on my carpal tunnel problem. In fact, I have liked DFW more for his essays than his fiction. His two collections that came out while he was alive popped with verve and straight-up awesomeness. He was a more literate version of Chuck Klosterman.

    So it is my luck that "Both Flesh and Not" is a collection of his nonfiction.
    It is good.
    In places.
    With caveats.
    It is not an organic whole. Some of the pieces are well-thought and developed criticism or insightful sports criticism, while there is a couple of paragraphs that were put up on the internet in the late nineties. This is more of an assemblage or a collage, but it does show the breadth and depth of DFWs mind and concerns.
    Im not going to go piece-by-piece, but one of the last works in the collection I think contains a valediction and a summation of his life (Though utterly impossible): "In sum, to really try to be informed and literate today is to feel stupid nearly all the time, and to need help." (Deciderization 2007 - A Special Report, 316)
    We miss you, Dave.
  • Patrick Von Maryland

    Patrick Von Maryland


    Outside of a couple of essays that involved Men’s tennis that are dated to the era but still worth reading,these have gotten better with age.The next to last essay on Decridization 2007 is excellent,and though it was a poke at 2007 cultural figures,it holds up well in what is now the information overload age.Another essay on male sexuality in the post-Aids era is excellent,it fuels the Gen X narrative that we are living in a World that was destroyed by boomers but we got the blame.DFW is a voice that is sadly lost at this time of Chaos.
  • Roland Martinez

    Roland Martinez


    I had read some of the essays in this collection in other places. My first ever introduction to DFW was in his introduction to the Best American Essays that talked about how one goes about deciding what essay is a best essay. Ive read a lot of Wallaces work but I think I finally figured out his Shtick, Wallace will find a very complex subject and then painstakingly make it simple and explain it to you. He will then point out what is absurd or foolish about said subject and leave you feeling like you are the smartest person in the room because you "get" what is so funny about something that you never knew existed a few paragraphs before. His talent for this is on display here in his essays on tennis, language and an outstanding essay about Terminator 2 which turns into an indictment on feminism in films, James Cameron as a sellout etc. Wallace is also at his best as a sensitive human being in essays about our post 9/11 reaction and how we have turned sex into a commodity. Im proudly going to keep this next to my almost complete library of DFW stuff and Im glad I took the time to read it.
  • The Ginger Man

    The Ginger Man


    Any Wallace publication is an event especially since his unique voice has been prematurely silenced. Unfortunately, Both Flesh and Not is a not altogether successful effort sweeping together previously uncollected pieces. The fifteen essays, some as thin as a few pages in length, are supplemented by many pages of word lists that Wallace apparently kept updating on his computer.

    More than half of the essays are devoted to literary subjects including an NYT Book Review of a Borges biography, the introduction to the 2007 edition of Best American Essays and a lengthy, and somewhat challenging, discussion of David Marksons Wittgensteins Mistress. In another entry, Wallace presents the young novelists of the eighties as products of university training and television ubiquity before predicting that, despite these challenges, his peers "are going to make art, maybe great art, maybe even great art change."

    The most accessible works in this book, however, include a tennis piece originally titled "Federer as Religious Experience." On full display here are Wallaces deep knowledge of and love for the game of tennis. In his paean to the skill of Federer, Wallace tells of the evolution of the power baseline game made possible by improved racket technology while giving some idea of what it looks like to stare down the barrel of a 90 mph volley in real life as opposed to the foreshortened view of a television screen.

    Wallace improbably makes a readable entry out of Terminator 2. This movie has seminal impact, he argues, because it is the first great example of special effects porn (6 scenes of action between vast stretches of banality.) Wallace posits the Inverse Cost and Quality Law: "The more lavish and spectacular a movies special effects, the shittier the movie is going to be in all non-F/X aspects."

    His genius is most conspicuously on display in his Wittgenstein analysis and as he brings his own unique perspective to often discussed public issues like the HIV virus and 9/11. Wallace poses unasked questions from unusual angles. In Back in New Fire, the author wonders if the danger of heterosexual AIDS will increase sexual passion by adding risk. "Nobodyd claim that a lethal epidemic is a good thing," says Wallace, but "an erotically charged human existence requires impediments to passion, prices for choices." A short entry about 9/11 asks whether we should consider a minimum baseline vulnerability to terrorist attack as part of the price of the American idea much as highway deaths are an assumed cost of the mobility and autonomy conferred by the automobile.

    "We need narrative like we need space-time. Its a built in thing," submits Wallace. His fiction and non fiction support this vision. Both Flesh and Not is not his finest effort but it is Wallace, and that makes it readable at worst and, in its finest moments, compelling.
  • Sonoma Mann

    Sonoma Mann


    Smarter people than I can describe DFWs incandescent prose. But did they notice the geeky little pun in the last two words of the title, like I just did after like ten years? (Its a Boolean operator, "AND NOT").

    Like Elvis, DFW will never die. (He haunts libraries rather than Wal-Mart parking lots.) Rock on, DFW.
  • Jan Smitowicz, Author

    Jan Smitowicz, Author


    This is one of three narrative nonfiction / essay collections published by the brilliant, sui generis David Foster Wallace. A Supposedly Fun Thing and Consider the Lobster are both better than this one, but Both Flesh and Not is still a fabulous read that--like all his books--somehow manages [usually with incredible success] to be entertaining and deeply thought-provoking at the same time. There are a few pieces Id consider duds, and it seems like this one is quite a bit less suffused with verve and significance and pure joie de vivre than those prior two. Given that this was published after his death, if Im not mistaken, you dont have Wallaces rabid perfectionism to sift out the duds. There are a few self-indulgent pieces that dont offer a whole lot--at least compared with the typical dizzyingly spectacular standards set by this wordslinger-god. Still very enjoyable though, and worth reading [after his first two essay collections, that is].
  • M. Dale

    M. Dale


    The essays in this book range from light fare to an in depth analysis of a novel based on Wittgensteins atomic philosophy. The title refers to a lovely piece about Roger Federer and the US Open, an amazing synthesis of a genius writing about a genius. Every piece is thoughtful, slightly sarcastic, and just plain beautiful.
  • Robert Plyler

    Robert Plyler


    And so it was that after a long wait, David Foster Wallaces final novel hit the world with a crash! Then, perhaps knocked from the trees by the Pale Kings vibrations, came this. If this were another author Id have given this collection 1 star, but even when Wallace was more interested in showing off how smart he was than in actually saying something with that rocket ship of a brain, he is still an incredibly thought-provoking read. I read this hot on the heels of D.T. Maxs biography of Wallace, and the early essays especially feel like ideas that Wallace himself later retreated from and thinking he tried to rectify in his later work. The best piece in here is probably the Federer article from the NY Times Play magazine which is available for free. Check it out; Googles a thing. While this isnt as transparent a cynical cash grab as "This is Water," it doesnt feel like it could be of too much interest to anyone outside Wallace historians, of which there must be at least, what, 30? If youre interested in seeing what all the fuss is about, I highly recommend picking up "Consider the Lobster" instead and moving on to "Oblivion" to see if his fiction writing is for you. If you read Wallaces entire oeuvre and miss this one, youre not missing anything much.
  • AFriendIndeed

    AFriendIndeed


    DFW is my favorite author. This was a nice addition to my bookshelf. The essays cover a huge range of time in DFWs career and most I had not read before.

    My biggest complaint is the layout of the word lists that precede each essay. They are interesting and fun to look at, but I do not think the cross-page layout is not the most effective choice.

    If you are a fan of DFWs nonfiction, you must read this book.
Looking for...?